✨Creating an account only takes 20 seconds, and doesn’t require any personal info.
If you’ve got one already, please log in.🤝
Difference between revisions of “Postilion sentence”
From Teflpedia
m (Text replacement - "category:index" to "{{index}}") |
|||
| (6 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
A '''postilion sentence''', from the oft-cited [[phrase]] | A '''postilion sentence''', from the oft-cited [[phrase]] “My postilion has been struck by lightning",<ref>Wikipedia, [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_postillion_has_been_struck_by_lightning#cite_note-thurber-11 My postillion has been struck by lightning, reference 11]</ref> is an example of [[language]] which, although grammatically correct, has "little or no chance of ever being useful in real life.”<ref>[http://davidcrystal.com/DC_articles/Clinical7.pdf Crystal, David “Postilion Sentences" ''Journal of Clinical Speech and Language Studies'' pp. 12–22 (1995) ]</ref> | ||
As [[David Crystal]] points out, "it conveys a structural meaning, and a lexical content, but that is all. | As [[David Crystal]] points out, "it conveys a structural meaning, and a lexical content, but that is all.” | ||
This is the epitome of [[classroom]] language teaching far removed from the needs of [[student]]s. Such phrases remind us of the need for teaching [[language]] that has a direct bearing on the present or future communicative needs of language learners. | This is the epitome of [[classroom]] language teaching far removed from the needs of [[student]]s. Such phrases remind us of the need for teaching [[language]] that has a direct bearing on the present or future communicative needs of language learners. | ||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
== Famous postilions == | == Famous postilions == | ||
* | *“My tailor is rich.” Very well known in Spain and popularized by “Asterix in Britain", is the first sentence of the Assimil method.<ref>Wikipedia, [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Assimil&oldid=690029659#Influences Assimil - Influences], version of 10 November 2015.</ref> | ||
* | *“My hovercraft is full of eels.” In fact invented by Monty Python, but well known on the internet.<ref>Wikipedia, [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirty_Hungarian_Phrasebook#cite_note-1 Dirty Hungarian Phrasebook, reference 1]</ref> | ||
== Other postilions == | == Other postilions == | ||
* | *“Who is this man/woman in my bed?" <small>Allegedly from a Czechoslovakian phrase book.</small> | ||
* | *“The table is being bitten by the dog.” <small>Seen in a textbook exercise on the [[passive]] - what question or situation would realistically give rise to this statement?</small> | ||
*What colour are my trousers?" <small>Fairly typical teacher question.</small> | *What colour are my trousers?" <small>Fairly typical teacher question.</small> | ||
==References== | ==References== | ||
<references/> | <references/>{{index}} | ||
== External links == | == External links == | ||
Latest revision as of 07:13, 21 January 2023
A postilion sentence, from the oft-cited phrase “My postilion has been struck by lightning",[1] is an example of language which, although grammatically correct, has "little or no chance of ever being useful in real life.”[2]
As David Crystal points out, "it conveys a structural meaning, and a lexical content, but that is all.”
This is the epitome of classroom language teaching far removed from the needs of students. Such phrases remind us of the need for teaching language that has a direct bearing on the present or future communicative needs of language learners.
Famous postilions[edit | edit source]
- “My tailor is rich.” Very well known in Spain and popularized by “Asterix in Britain", is the first sentence of the Assimil method.[3]
- “My hovercraft is full of eels.” In fact invented by Monty Python, but well known on the internet.[4]
Other postilions[edit | edit source]
- “Who is this man/woman in my bed?" Allegedly from a Czechoslovakian phrase book.
- “The table is being bitten by the dog.” Seen in a textbook exercise on the passive - what question or situation would realistically give rise to this statement?
- What colour are my trousers?" Fairly typical teacher question.
References[edit | edit source]
- ↑ Wikipedia, My postillion has been struck by lightning, reference 11
- ↑ Crystal, David “Postilion Sentences" Journal of Clinical Speech and Language Studies pp. 12–22 (1995)
- ↑ Wikipedia, Assimil - Influences, version of 10 November 2015.
- ↑ Wikipedia, Dirty Hungarian Phrasebook, reference 1
